1. Whose graph it builds. Three answers exist. Firm platforms (Affinity, 4Degrees, Introhive) capture the firm's email and calendar, so the graph is the firm's and stops at the firm's inbox. Inferred platforms (Village, Vieu) layer a graph built from public records over what you connect, so coverage extends to people nobody on your side has met and the paths need checking. Personal platforms (Happenstance, Connect The Dots) build from the accounts each person connects, including the personal ones, and pool them through groups or a team.
2. Whether you are allowed to buy it. Four of the nine publish no price and sell only through a sales conversation. A solo investor, a founder or a five-person team is not the customer for those.
3. What a path is made of. A path built from a reply, a meeting or a shared thread is a relationship. A path inferred from two people having overlapped at an employer is a guess. Village's own data page labels only 7% of its edges direct; the rest are co-worker, role and alumni overlaps. Treat inferred paths as leads to verify before you spend a favor on one.
4. Where the answer arrives. Some tools answer the question in the product (Happenstance, Village, Affinity). Some hand you data to rank yourself or to pipe into another tool (The Swarm, Vieu). Both are legitimate; they are different purchases.
5. What it reads. Every tool here reads email or calendar activity in some form. Ask whether it reads headers or content, who inside the company can see whose relationships, and what happens to the graph when a person leaves. Happenstance reads email as headers only and each person's connections are visible to them, their friends and their groups.